Central Europe Review find out about advertising in CER
Vol 3, No 2
15 January 2001
front page 
our awards 
CER cited 
jobs at CER 
CER Direct 
e-mail us 
year 2000 
year 1999 
by subject 
by author 
EU Focus 
music shop 
video store 
find books 


Lenin: A Biography Another Look at Lenin
Lenin: A Biography
Harvard UP, 2000
ISBN 0674003306

Rob Stout

Of all the political figures of the last century, Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov, better known in history books as Vladimir Lenin, casts the longest historical shadow.

One could argue (and many have) that without the revolution he personally set into motion, the chain of events leading from the First World War to the Second, followed by a 50-year nuclear stand-off between the United States and the Soviet Union, would never have occurred. Likewise, the cast of characters that emerged—Stalin, Hitler and Mao, not to mention Churchill, Eisenhower, Nixon, Gorbachev and Reagan—could have never assumed their places on the world stage had it not been for this reordering of power.

The person behind the politics

Throughout this massive and exhaustive biography of Lenin, British historian Robert Service does not lose sight of his subject's stature as the father of the 20th century's feast of horrors.

What interests Service more, however, is an exploration of the person behind the political persona. While much has been published on Lenin's personal life, nothing has been written since the "unsealing" of the Soviet Party archives in 1991. Claiming to have had first access to this previously classified material, Service has diligently incorporated his archival findings into this work, which has enabled him to take issue with the many biographies that tend to portray Lenin as either a sociopath or savior.

Service, who is also the author of the three-volume Lenin: A Political Life, retains his disapproval of his subject's actions while remaining impartial to the point of avoiding judgments in favor of revealing more intimate facts, such as Lenin's regret over not being able to have children with his wife, what he read, ate and even how he liked to dress. Elsewhere in the biography we discover Lenin's natural playfulness with children and read that he carried his cat down the Kremlin hallways, stopping to turn off the lights in the offices of less conscientious comrades.

Lenin's record as a revolutionary

Interpersed among such interesting anecdotes is Lenin's record as a revolutionary. After taking Russia out of the First World War, he became locked in a life-or-death struggle to save the revolution that led to the extermination of entire classes of people. It is this "vicious relish in exemplary terror" that reduces the sensitive side of the man Service seems, at times, eager to emphasize.

The book's depiction of Lenin's actions once he is secure in his position as head of the Central Committee become less revelatory and confirm what other Western historians have maintained for some time. As a ruthless authoritarian, he exercised complete control over his associates, prohibiting the slightest debate among Central Committee members. More interesting were his unsentimental, and most often scathing, views of the common man whose interests he claimed to represent.

"A bookish fanatic"

In looking for explanations for these political traits in his subject's personal background, Service, like those before him, finds few answers. If anything, these new documents have left the author more beguiled than ever. The reader is presented with a picture of a personality rooted in paradox: a man driven by "an inner calling," yet outwardly governed by rigid self-control; a coldly calculating individual, nonetheless capable of deep emotion; a man who possessed little empathy, yet felt outraged at the slightest injustice.

Still trying to accommodate his original vision of Lenin as simply an ideologically driven zealot, while confronted with ample evidence of a man prone to "sadistic self-indulgence" in his use of terror to consolidate power, Service seems somewhat cavalier, summarizing his subject as "a bookish fanatic who felt no need to witness the violent activity of his revolution."

Send this article to a friend
While much of this may be true, it flies in the face of the revisionist claim the author makes in his preface. The author hopes that the advantage provided by recently unsealed archives will produce a picture of Lenin somewhere between saint and sinner, but comes away essentially agreeing with the other historians with whom he takes issue. Lenin was a brutal, politically driven man willing to dispose of anyone or anything that stood in the way of his objectives. That has been the traditional view, and this biography offers nothing to change this general consensus.

Although refutable on some points, this lucidly written, insightful biography will no doubt come to be regarded as a definitive interpretation of Lenin, at least until more documents surface in the Moscow archives or elsewhere in the former Soviet bloc.

Despite the ambiguities left in his wake, Service's final words say much about the man: "Let thanks be given" that there have been so few historical figures able to "turn the world upside down."

Rob Stout, 15 January 2001

Moving on:


Sam Vaknin
Women in Transition

Mel Huang
Gerrymandering in Estonia

Elena Gapova
Do Czechs Need Feminism?

Brian J Požun
Orthodox Christmas

Bernhard Seliger
Change in Germany

Gusztáv Kosztolányi
The King is Dead

Eva Sobotka
Schooling the Roma

Alex Smailes
Traveling the Caucasus

Konstantin Vulkov
Bulgaria's New Left

Radoslavova Branimira
European Defense

Czech TV Crisis
Jan Čulík
Public TV Dies

Anna-Britt Kaca
Prelude to a Crisis

Nukes in Kaliningrad
Joanna Rohozińska
The Bear Awakens

Mel Huang
Nuclear Neighbourhood

Rob Stout
Lenin: A Biography

Andrea Mrozek
The Meaning of Liberalism

Štěpán Kotrba NEW!
Sow and Reap

Brian J Požun
Shedding the Balkan Skin

Martin D Brown
Czech Historical Amnesia

Dejan Anastasijević (ed)
Out of Time

Gusztáv Kosztolányi
Hungarian Oil Scandal

Sam Vaknin
After the Rain

Press Reviews:
Andrea Mrozek
Germany: Playful Politicians

Oliver Craske
UK: Depleted Coverage

Roma NEW!

Mixed Nuts

CER eBookclub Members enter here